Gaza Peace Plan Scorecard Pub

Ceasefire in Name, Deprivation in Practice: One Year of Gaza's Failed Peace Plan

This scorecard evaluates the implementation of the ceasefire agreement outlined in the Trump administration’s 20-point Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict, as endorsed by UN Security Council Resolution 2803 (2025). It assesses progress against the plan’s stated objectives on civilian protection, humanitarian access, reconstruction and economic development, and freedom of movement.

The negotiators of the ceasefire presented it not only as a way to stop the fighting, but as the foundation for a fundamentally better reality in Gaza, one that would deliver stability, humanitarian relief, and the beginnings of recovery. The Plan carried the full weight of Security Council authorization and the backing of a broader group of UN Member states who supported the initiative on the premise that it would end the mass killings of civilians and improve conditions for Palestinians in Gaza.

At the six-month mark, the April 2026 scorecard rated the ceasefire as failing. It earned just 5 of 26 possible points overall and zero out of 10 on humanitarian access. At that point, more than 700 Palestinians had been killed since the ceasefire began. Fewer than 100 UN-coordinated aid trucks were entering a day, against a minimum of 600. Over 50 percent of Gaza remained under Israeli military control. Six months later, every one of those measures has worsened. At the one-year mark, the ceasefire earns just 4 of 26 possible points

Author

Oxfam

Publication date

Publication type

Briefing paper

Share this publication: